Should You Get Two Dogs from the Same Litter? Pros and Cons You Need to Know

Bringing home a new puppy is exciting. So, when faced with two adorable littermates, it's easy to think, "Why not both?" Raising sibling dogs—also called "littermates"—can be rewarding but comes with unique challenges. Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons so you can make an informed decision.

The Pros of Raising Littermates dogs

1. Built-in companionship

Littermates have already bonded. They eat, sleep, and play together from birth. Adopting them both means they won't be lonely or bored when you're not around. This can reduce separation anxiety and destructive behaviour in the early months.

2. Synchronized routines

You can train, feed, walk, and play with both dogs simultaneously. This can save time—at least in theory—and create a smooth rhythm for daily care.

3. Easier socialization—with each other

Dogs need social contact to stay emotionally healthy. Having a sibling around provides constant interaction and stimulation, especially while they still learn to behave around other dogs.

4. Shared energy

Puppies have endless energy. When they have a playmate, they can burn each other out—making your job easier regarding exercise and mental stimulation.

The Cons of Raising Littermates

1. Littermate Syndrome

This is real, and it's not a myth. Some sibling pairs become overly dependent on each other, forming a tight bond that interferes with their development. Symptoms include:

Extreme distress when separated

Poor focus during training

Fearfulness or aggression toward people or other dogs

Not every pair experiences it, but when it happens, it's a serious behavioural issue that can take years to fix.

2. Double the work

While training two dogs at once seems convenient, it usually doesn't work out that way. You'll need to do separate training sessions so each dog can focus. This means double the time, effort, and consistency.

3. Cost

Everything doubles: food, vet bills, grooming, gear, training classes. If one dog gets sick or injured, the other might, too. Financial strain is real and should be factored in from day one.

4. It is harder to bond individually

Dogs need a strong relationship with their humans. When they have each other, they may not need to engage with you as much. You have to work harder to build individual trust and connection with each pup.

Tips If You Decide to Adopt Littermates

Crate them separately. They need alone time from day one to get used to being apart.

Train them separately. This helps them develop focus and independence.

Give individual attention. Walk them separately sometimes. Play with them one-on-one.

Watch for behavior issues early. If you see signs of littermate syndrome, work with a professional trainer.

Bottom Line

Raising two dogs from the same litter isn't impossible, but it's not for everyone. It can work well if you're an experienced dog owner with the time, patience, and resources to give each dog what it needs individually. If you're new to dog ownership or want a simpler experience, starting with one pup might be smarter.

Should You Get Two Dogs from the Same Litter? Pros and Cons You Need to Know